The Mutual Group Appoints Tom Troy as CEO
The Mutual Group, LLC, a significant player in the insurance sector, has announced the appointment of Tom Troy as its new Chief Executive Officer. Troy’s tenure will commence on January 5, 2026, marking a new chapter for the company. With an extensive background spanning over three decades in the insurance industry, Troy brings a wealth of experience and a proven track record of leadership to The Mutual Group.
Table of contents
Official guidance: NAIC — official guidance for People Moves Mutual Group Names Troy Canada Overview
Troy’s Extensive Industry Experience

Tom Troy’s career is distinguished by his involvement with several prominent insurance carriers, including leadership positions at both mutual and reciprocal companies. His deep understanding of the insurance landscape, coupled with his experience in strategic roles, positions him well to lead The Mutual Group. Prior to this appointment, Troy held the position of Chief Transformation Officer at USAA, a well-regarded financial services provider. His responsibilities at USAA focused on driving strategic initiatives and operational improvements.
Before his role at USAA, Troy served as the Chief Executive Officer and President of CSAA Insurance Group. During his time there, he demonstrated his ability to lead and manage a complex organization, navigating the challenges of the insurance market. His experience extends beyond executive leadership, encompassing product development, distribution channel management, and the implementation of technology-driven solutions. This multifaceted experience makes him a valuable asset to The Mutual Group.
Strategic Vision and Value Delivery

As Chief Executive Officer, Troy will be instrumental in shaping and executing The Mutual Group’s strategic vision. His responsibilities include expanding the company’s platform and enhancing the value delivered to its members. With the insurance industry constantly evolving, Troy’s experience in adapting to market changes and implementing innovative solutions will be crucial to The Mutual Group’s continued success. His focus on member value aligns with the core principles of mutual insurance companies, which prioritize the interests of their policyholders.
The Mutual Group anticipates that Troy’s leadership will drive growth and innovation, enabling the company to better serve its members and navigate the competitive insurance market. His appointment reflects The Mutual Group’s commitment to attracting top talent and investing in leadership that can guide the company through future challenges and opportunities.
Prior Roles and Industry Impact
Before leading CSAA, Troy held the position of Executive Vice President at Allstate, where he oversaw a substantial portfolio of non-Allstate brands, including Esurance, Ivantage, Encompass, and business insurance. This role provided him with experience in managing a diverse range of insurance products and distribution channels. His responsibilities at Allstate involved strategic decision-making and operational oversight, contributing to the overall success of the insurer’s various brands.
Earlier in his career, Troy held Executive Vice President roles at Liberty Mutual and senior leadership positions with Safeco Insurance. These experiences have provided him with a comprehensive understanding of the insurance industry, spanning various types of insurance products and distribution models. His extensive background in leadership roles demonstrates his ability to manage large teams, drive strategic initiatives, and achieve business objectives. His diverse experiences across multiple major insurance carriers will be invaluable in his new role at The Mutual Group.
Looking Ahead with The Mutual Group
The appointment of Tom Troy as CEO signals a new era for The Mutual Group. His extensive experience, strategic vision, and focus on member value position him well to lead the company forward. The insurance industry faces numerous challenges, including evolving customer expectations, technological advancements, and regulatory changes. Troy’s leadership will be essential in navigating these challenges and ensuring The Mutual Group remains a competitive and successful organization. The industry will be watching to see how his vision unfolds in the coming years.
Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results. Investment decisions should be based on thorough research and consultation with a financial advisor.
Financial Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources: Information based on credible sources and industry analysis.
Explore more: related articles.